One late night almost ten years ago, Nilla and I were out driving near Page, Arizona. In the dark and without GPS, I was trying to find a Best Western motel which I had been able to book at a rather incredible $40 rate. It seemed like a steal since every picture on their website looked really scenic. However, the reason for the low rate would soon be all too clear, as the motel had two “wings”, one facing the beauty of Lake Powell and the other a 2,250-megawatt coal-fired power plant called the “Navajo Generating Station” (obviously, our room was in the latter wing). Not only was the view highly dystopian, the power plant also produced a fair amount of noise, which made sleeping rather difficult.
Looking out at the coal power plant at night, I remember thinking that this is what we are doing to the planet and ourselves. Rather than the clean high-energy future envisioned in
Star Trek (which, by the way, is
turning fifty on Thursday), we are burning through brownish-black minerals of fossilized carbon. To me, coal is somehow emblematic “Ork-tech”. It is the kind of technology that we should have left behind decades ago, were it not for irrational fears of nuclear energy. Thus, it is somewhat ironic that the greatest achievement of the so-called “environmental movement” may be that it has made the world safe for coal.
And now, it seems that I have had better luck and scored a more permanent upgrade to the wing with the “lake view”. As the construction of the neighbourhood is almost finished, it feels nearly as idyllic as Hobbiton, with kids playing and lots of green stuff. If only people would share a moral commitment to making this universal rather than taking it as an unreflected privilege or, worse, pursuing “feel good” policies that will keep the rest of the world trapped in fossil Mordor.